Comments on: Margaret Wente’s plagiarism problem http://sistersagesmusings.ca/2012/09/19/margaret-wentes-plagiarism-problem/ Center-left blog from Canadians across the country and beyond Thu, 27 Jun 2013 09:45:28 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.5.2 By: Jymn http://sistersagesmusings.ca/2012/09/19/margaret-wentes-plagiarism-problem/comment-page-1/#comment-9846 Jymn Thu, 20 Sep 2012 19:27:36 +0000 http://sistersagesmusings.ca/?p=12956#comment-9846 Yes Omar, I have. While my decade of professional writing involved music not politics, I know the pressure of deadlines, fighting with editors and defending unpopular articles and reviews. I don’t count as work though, especially at $250K/yr, writing poorly-conceived articles that promote one party over another without backing them up with facts and art. Wente fails in presenting cogent arguments; her articles often come off as amateurish polemics that hunger for eloquence and passion. Most of all, seemingly the purpose of her writing appears to be the promotion of the Conservative party while painting youth, the centre and left, and working people as dirty fucking hippies. She is at once smug, so ill-informed she seems from another time long ago. But that’s not the worst of it. Her writing is often more akin to propaganda than to analysis or professional, competent writing.

My rant as you call it brought up an important aspect that others have noted about Wente – she appears to plagiarize, the very reason I wrote the post – a point you overlooked in your comment. The other blog I linked to presents some credible instances of what appears to be blatant mosaic plagiarism. That nobody but bloggers (and there are many who have noted Wente’s questionable ethics) dares to challenge Wente speaks volumes about our media’s timidity in addressing journalists’ failings.

If you would have gone through the claims of plagiarism and rebutted them with reasoned proof, I would have a greater respect for your opinion of Margaret Wente’s journalistic skills and ethics.

]]>
By: OMM http://sistersagesmusings.ca/2012/09/19/margaret-wentes-plagiarism-problem/comment-page-1/#comment-9845 OMM Thu, 20 Sep 2012 19:06:11 +0000 http://sistersagesmusings.ca/?p=12956#comment-9845 While I don’t agree with your general assertion, I don’t think it’s fair to say “writing occasional commentary for a Conservative newspaper is not work”. Have you ever tried writing a column that’s actually slated for print publication? (blog posts don’t count)

Whether for a Conservative or Liberal paper, there’s a reason columnists get paid quite a bit more than reporters. It’s easy to rant – it’s difficult to state an opinion eloquently, passionately, and concisely on a daily or weekly basis.

]]>